IAUS241 Challenge 1
By A. Vazdekis, A.J. Cenarro, A. de Lorenzo-Caceres & M. Beasley (IAC, Tenerife, Spain)
The theoretical parameters of the isochrones have been transformed to
the observational plane (colours and magnitudes) by using relations
inferred on the basis of extensive empirical photometric stellar
libraries.
We use the metallicity-dependent empirical relations of Alonso,
Arribas & Martinez-Roger (1996, 1999), for dwarfs and giants
respectively.
The empirical (not the theoretical) compilation of Lejeune,
Cuisinier & Buser (1997, 1998; and references therein) are used for
the coolest dwarfs (Teff < 4000 K) and giants (Teff < 3500 K),
respectively, for solar metallicity. A semi-empirical approach was
applied to other metallicities on the basis of these relations and the
model atmospheres of Bessell et al. (1989, 1991) and the library of
Fluks et al. (1994). The empirical compilation of Lejeune et al. was
also used for stars with temperatures above ~ 8000 K.
Metal-dependent bolometric correction given by Alonso, Arribas &
Martinez-Roger (1995, 1999) for dwarfs and giants have been applied
respectively. For the Sun, a bolometric correction BC_sun=-0.12 and a
bolometric magnitude of 4.70 has been used according to these
authors.
We have carried out a "by eye" fitting procedure, trying to fit (1) the top main sequence plus the turn-off; (2) the subgiant and red giant branches (the later specially at low magnitudes, as the redder part of the RGB is not very well constrained); and (3) the magnitude of the horizontal branch base. Reddening effects have not been considered; instead, apropriate offsets in both axis have been applied to the isochrones to match the observational CMD.
The Table below lists the "best" ages and metallicities of the program clusters for 4 different isochrone sets. No age/metallicity interpolation between isochrones has been carried out, so the values here derived should be considered as the "closest" solutions. By clicking at the solutions, you will be redirected to the corresponding CMD fits. Notes to the fits: red points are employed to display the observational CMD of the cluster, whilst the white line represents the isochrone whose age and metallicity are labeled within the figure. When the density of stars at a given magnitude bin of the CMD is large enough, green circles indicate the "mode" of the colour distribution (X-axis) within that magnitude bin. It may help to find the "most" populated region of the CMD when many stars are overplotted (note also that it may be wrongly determined at noisy and/or bimodal regions!).
| |
CMD type |
Padova 1994 |
Padova 2000 |
Salasnich 2000 (scaled-solar) |
Salasnich 2000 (alpha-enhanced) |
| 47Tuc | B-V vs B |
Age: 16 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.7 dex |
Age: 14 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.7 dex |
Age: 14 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
Age: 14 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.4 dex |
| M67 | B-V vs V |
Age: 5 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex (1) |
Age: 4 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
Age: 3 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.3 dex |
Age: 4 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
| V-I vs V |
Age: 4 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex (1) |
Age: 4 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.4 dex |
Age: 4 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
Age: 4 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex (1) |
|
| NGC1805 | V-I vs V |
Age: 0.05 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex (3) |
Age: 0.06 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.4 dex |
Too young for available isochrones |
Too young for available isochrones |
| NGC1868 | V-I vs V |
Age: 0.8 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.7 dex (1,2) |
Age: 0.8 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.4 dex (1,2) |
Age: 0.6 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.4 dex (1,2) |
Age: 0.8 Gyr [Fe/H]: -0.4 dex (1,2) |
| NGC6528 | V-I vs V |
Age: 13 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
Age: 13 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
Age: 13 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.3 dex |
Age: 13 Gyr [Fe/H]: 0.0 dex |
(1) Not possible to fit both the MSTO and the HB level
(2) MSTO morphology (peak) not reproduced by the observations
(3) Not possible to fit the MSTO